+- Woodnet Forums (https://forums.woodnet.net)
+-- Thread: Thanks, Rob! (/showthread.php?tid=7321605)
Pages:
1
2
Thanks, Rob! - AHill - 08-11-2016
Just when I thought I had some money in my wallet, Lee Valley goes and introduces Veritas Mortise Chisels. Available in A2 or PM-V11. A2 anywhere from $65 to $69 each. PM-V11 anywhere from $85 to $105 each.
![[Image: 05s3102s01.jpg]](http://www.leevalley.com/US/images/item/Woodworking/Chisels/05s3102s01.jpg)
RE: Thanks, Rob! - Strokes77 - 08-11-2016
So are they sash type chisels, or more like tapered pig sticker style? I can't tell from the marketing.
RE: Thanks, Rob! - Gregory of Sherwood Forest - 08-11-2016
Aww, geez.
You just had to go ahead and post this, didn't you? I hadn't seen these yet, and my wallet is dragging me into other wants right now.
I have the full set of LV PM-V11 bench chisels. I guess these will have to be added, too.
RE: Thanks, Rob! - DCarr10760 - 08-11-2016
Look at those rounded bevels! That seems like a good idea.
DC
RE: Thanks, Rob! - Gary™ - 08-11-2016
This is a timely post. I've been waiting for the Ray Illes chisels to be restocked for a long time. These seem comparable
RE: Thanks, Rob! - Window Guy - 08-12-2016
Those are beauties for sure, but so far my Narrex Chisels work just fine.
Steve
RE: Thanks, Rob! - smoothjazz27 - 08-12-2016
Lee Valley comes through again with another winner in these mortise chisels!! I just purchased my first LV PM-V11 Bench Chisel last month, and what a difference in feel and performance to the bench chisels I currently own. I hope to sell all the old bench chisels I have, and hopefully have enough money to purchase another one of the fine bench chisels. I have a decent set of mortise chisels that I picked up over the years, but I know where to turn if I need any new ones, or one just happens to get lost or damaged
RE: Thanks, Rob! - Admiral - 08-12-2016
Nice chisels for sure and they fill a void in LV's premium chisel line, but somehow, for chopping mortises, I question the "need" for the V11 steel, seems like total overkill; I can't remember a time I ever had to sharpen mortise chisels in mid job because of dullness, and I have what I think is O1 in my Sorby mortising chisels. Bench chisels, paring chisels where you are doing fine work, sure, I can see why fudge would want V11, but mortise? I really don't see the value add for this application. I think LV gets it, as they are also available for 25% less in A1, which should be quite serviceable for most any wood. I guess LV's logic is if you went to the trouble of developing the V11, why not offer it. Others may differ......
RE: Thanks, Rob! - Window Guy - 08-12-2016
Hmmmmm never thought about it that way Rich but I have to agree with you. I guess it is the bling factor, but I am not knocking them by no means as they offer excellent tools.
Steve
RE: Thanks, Rob! - Bibliophile 13 - 08-12-2016
They sure look nice. I'd call them a "sash mortise chisel" style, just because of the shape of the handles, and the hoops. I'm sure they're very, very nice.
But like Admiral, I've never had to resharpen a mortise chisel mid-mortise, and I use the cheap Narex ones. I'll admire them from afar, but I won't be buying them.