New on Saw Plate Tensioning :)

New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - Printable Version

+- Woodnet Forums (https://forums.woodnet.net)
+-- Thread: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) (/showthread.php?tid=7334658)

Pages: 1 2

New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - C. in Indy - 11-11-2017

I recall "tensioning of [plate] saws" to be a super controversial topic. (No argument on the actual tensioning of fret saws though.)

Now check this out!

https://www.instagram.com/p/BXVz8sthYz_/?taken-by=skelton_saws

https://www.skeltonsaws.co.uk/mallard-saw

Chris

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - Strokes77 - 11-11-2017

(11-11-2017, 09:30 AM)C. in Indy Wrote: I recall "tensioning of [plate] saws" to be a super controversial topic. (No argument on the actual tensioning of fret saws though.)

Now check this out!

https://www.instagram.com/p/BXVz8sthYz_/?taken-by=skelton_saws

https://www.skeltonsaws.co.uk/mallard-saw

Chris

Enter it into the Rube Goldberg challenge?

Or

Greatest achievement in modern sawmaking?

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - Admiral - 11-11-2017

I read the information at the website, and am still scratching my head about the "adjustable blade" aspect. But for US$1250 it would have to cut wood by itself for me to buy it......
Laugh

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - enjuneer - 11-11-2017

While the Mallard does have a hefty price tag, it embodies several features not seen before in saw design. Besides the aforementioned tensioning mechanism, the saw plate never touches wood and therefore is not subject to deflection due to seasonal changes in the wood. If that does not impress you, then the exquisite attention to detail should. Shane Skelton studied as a gunmaker with one of the classic English shotgun companies before embarking on his sawmaking enterprise.

These photos were posted on Facebook by Richard Arnold in September (I saved them to a Flickr album since the forum doesn't allow hotlinking to Facebook content).

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - Strokes77 - 11-11-2017

Super cool saw. I hope my joke isn't taken the wrong way. Looks awesome and well made, and I bet it cuts great.

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - enjuneer - 11-11-2017

(11-11-2017, 11:17 AM)Strokes77 Wrote: Super cool saw. I hope my joke isn't taken the wrong way. Looks awesome and well made, and I bet it cuts great.

Everything revolutionary is generally looked at with a skeptical eye at first. I would like to see more of this line of thinking in the future. Hopefully, it will trickle down to the tools that us mortals can afford.

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - hbmcc - 11-11-2017

(11-11-2017, 11:32 AM)enjuneer Wrote: Everything revolutionary is generally looked at with a skeptical eye at first. I would like to see more of this line of thinking in the future. Hopefully, it will trickle down to the tools that us mortals can afford.

I think you can do it yourself, now. Don't read the marketing blurb and study the tool. Blended tooth filing (rip/cc) is a happening thing. The back on my TFWW kit saw is single piece. The difference is a two-piece handle, brass/bronze and funky wood rejected from fine furniture use. It must have a heck of a set; but why be cutting swampy wood that seizes so easily?

Nice bling. It's a pretty tool. Does Blontz charge that much for his?

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - AHill - 11-11-2017

No doubt, a technological tour de force, but it solves a problem that doesn't exist. Seriously. I can buy 10 LN dovetail saws for the price of one Mallard.

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - enjuneer - 11-11-2017

(11-11-2017, 01:55 PM)AHill Wrote: No doubt, a technological tour de force, but it solves a problem that doesn't exist. Seriously. I can buy 10 LN dovetail saws for the price of one Mallard.

I will have to reserve final judgement on the plate tensioning device until I actually have a chance to try one. However, I find plenty of old backsaws with handles warped enough to bend the blade. Shane Skelton's reinforced handle alleviates that issue. Also, since the spine is integral to the handle and does not rely on the mortise for strength, the spine itself can be made lighter, thereby shifting the balance of the saw closer to the hand. Everyone has their preferences, of course, but I prefer a saw that is more neutrally balanced.

RE: New on Saw Plate Tensioning :) - Admiral - 11-11-2017

(11-11-2017, 01:55 PM)AHill Wrote: No doubt, a technological tour de force, but it solves a problem that doesn't exist. Seriously. I can buy 10 LN dovetail saws for the price of one Mallard.