+- Woodnet Forums (https://www.forums.woodnet.net)
+-- Thread: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site (/showthread.php?tid=7350999)
Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - hbmcc - 10-29-2019
WoodNet is officially the Lost Art Complaint Department, or; Butt of Lost Art P. Please welcome the chaff or those who have the gaul to question CS's misanthropy.
Today he is making contoured plywood chairs after having an epiphany last night.
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - MarkSingleton - 10-29-2019
Meh. Chris is a good guy. I have learned stuff from his books that I have.
How to really use a bench plane for instance.
I read his stuff online when I remember to go there.
Is he always right? No, is anyone?
I do know that when he was with Popular Woodworking ( in several different
ways ) I found the magazine a good read. Since then, not so much. In fact,
my subscription has run out and I doubt I will resubscribe.
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - DonSlaughter - 10-29-2019
Misanthropy???? Really?? Chris has done more for the craft than most contemporary writers. I've followed and appreciated his views since he began editing PW and never knew him to be anything but fair and honest. I met him in person twice and chatted.... he is very down-to-earth and I've never witnessed grandiosity nor haughty attitude. He has well thought out principles and presents honest versions of his perceptions & experience in his books and articles. I have differing opinions about some of the things he has said but respect him for his tenacity and integrity. I think we Woodnetters are fortunate to have him in our midst.
just sayin
Don
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - Stwood_ - 10-29-2019
Huh. Guess I'll have to find the article link.
I haven't read his blog lately.
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - Stwood_ - 10-30-2019
I found 4-5 references (and links) about WN being the complaint dept. Official dept? No idea...Lol
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - Tony Z - 10-30-2019
I've said before and I'll say it again, Swartz's real talent is in publishing, and writing (though some don't like his sophomoric style!). It's refreshing to make such woodworking classics, again available. I hope Lost Arts Is around for a long, long time!
As far as his woodworking styles, that's more a personal opinion, for those of us with decades under our belts, whether or not we subscribe to his techniques. His tool business? Again a personal opinion of your work habits and perceived tool needs.
I did see the mention in his blog about forum comments, but given his writing style, I viewed it at about 2/3s tongue in cheek.
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - AHill - 10-30-2019
I really don't agree with using WoodNet to tear down an individual. We can comment on his projects, but to simply invite unbounded criticism is unfair. I know he invited the criticism by posting a link to WoodNet and labeling it "Complaint Office." Go ahead and collect the complaints. I doubt a single one of us is or will be as successful as Chris in the woodworking world.
Schwarz was the single biggest influence for me getting into hand tools. He's a smart guy. He's an entrepreneur. His tenure at Popular Woodworking was probably the best years they've experienced in recent history.
BTW, you failed to mention the plywood chair was inspired by a dream he had after taking melatonin to combat jet lag. And, what's wrong with building a chair out of plywood, anyway? Since when has Schwarz ever claimed he was a hand tools only woodworker?
Here's the link to his blog:
https://blog.lostartpress.com/2019/10/28/the-itchy-scratchy-design-process/
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - Philip1231 - 10-30-2019
BIG fan of Chris Schwartz here: I suggest you could be completely wrong in your assessment of him.
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - Derek Cohen - 10-30-2019
I thought that Chris' comment was hilarious!
Regards from Perth
Derek
RE: Chriz Schwarz Dump-On Site - Rob Young - 10-30-2019
(10-30-2019, 12:38 AM)Stwood_ Wrote: I found 4-5 references (and links) about WN being the complaint dept. Official dept? No idea...Lol
And he probably paid at least the $6 required too.