Posts: 139
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2004
I'm having difficulties sharpening my card scraper. It's a recent purchase from Peachtree WW and I got a Crown burnisher as well. It actually came with a decent hook. I played with it a bit making some shavings and then wanted to move on to practice renewing the edge.
I've watched several different video techniques, mainly following
this. I made the file guide, honed til shiney, and began burnishing. I'm scratching the heck out of the burnishing tool but cannot get a hook. I'm holding the tool at about 5-10 degree angle to the scrapers edge and using quite firm pressure.
Does anyone have any additional tips I could employ-- amount of pressure, hone longer, 'roll' or burnish the face edge harder? I'm curious if the scraper itself is too hard and possibly that is the main trouble.
Did it come easier to you? Thanks!
WoodWorking Poser
--Daniel
Posts: 286
Threads: 0
Joined: Apr 2007
Daniel said:
I'm having difficulties sharpening my card scraper. It's a recent purchase from Peachtree WW and I got a Crown burnisher as well. It actually came with a decent hook. I played with it a bit making some shavings and then wanted to move on to practice renewing the edge.
I've watched several different video techniques, mainly following this. I made the file guide, honed til shiney, and began burnishing. I'm scratching the heck out of the burnishing tool but cannot get a hook. I'm holding the tool at about 5-10 degree angle to the scrapers edge and using quite firm pressure.
Does anyone have any additional tips I could employ-- amount of pressure, hone longer, 'roll' or burnish the face edge harder? I'm curious if the scraper itself is too hard and possibly that is the main trouble.
Did it come easier to you? Thanks!
Try a series of strokes gradually increasing in pressure until you feel the hook. If you use too much force the hook will get rolled back toward the scraper.
Posts: 639
Threads: 0
Joined: Mar 2008
Daniel,
Here is a video of the process I use. It has proven quick and repeatable for me.
Card Scraper Rob Millard
www.americanfederalperiod.com
Posts: 124
Threads: 0
Joined: Mar 2010
The crown burnisher has a reputation for being soft. I use a length of high speed steel drill rod
Occasional musings on my blog:
bridgerberdel.wordpress.com
Posts: 7,008
Threads: 0
Joined: Aug 2004
Location: Perth, Australia
Hi Daniel
Rob's video is very good. The part that needs emphasising is "drawing out" the steel edge. Unless this is done you will struggle to turn a hook. This is the most common omission made by those starting out.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Posts: 12,283
Threads: 0
Joined: Jun 2007
Location: Bucks County PA
bridger said:
The crown burnisher has a reputation for being soft. I use a length of high speed steel drill rod
Unless the HSS has a hardness of about Rc 60, it also might not work.
I highly recommend buying a Hock burnisher or making your own. You can buy a 1/4" dia tungsten carbide rod from ENCO for about $10 and have a super high quality burnisher with minimal effort.
Carbide Rounds; Diameter: 0.1875; Material: Solid Carbide; Diameter (Inch): 3/16; Overall Length (Inch): 4; Material Grade: C2; Type: Solid Round
See ya around,
Dominic
------------------------------
Don't you love it when you ask someone what time it is and to prove how smart they are, they tell you how to build a watch?
Posts: 46,037
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2000
Daniel said:
I've watched several different video techniques, mainly following this. I made the file guide, honed til shiney, and began burnishing. I'm scratching the heck out of the burnishing tool but cannot get a hook. I'm holding the tool at about 5-10 degree angle to the scrapers edge and using quite firm pressure.
Did it come easier to you? Thanks!
3-4 pounds of pressure (i.e. light pressure) is all you need.
After that "AH HAH!" moment, it gets easy.
“The windows are open and I'm wearing pants.”
- Fire Wood
Posts: 10,718
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2006
Location: Orlando, Florida
It's kinda pricey, but this scraper from StewMac is one of the best I've used, and it holds and edge for a very long time compared to your standard card scraper. You sharpen it by turning a burr using your grinder.
StewMac Ultimate Scraper
Still Learning,
Allan Hill
Posts: 1,231
Threads: 0
Joined: Mar 2005
I like Daniel's process and will try it out.
I actually freehand file the edge and then stone the edge and two faces of the scraper with the scraper held about 1.5" high in a metal vise (I use just a 4000 grit stone - why? it works). Close enough to 90 degrees works fine on the edge - your eye is actually pretty good. On the faces, you're done when your wet stone sticks to the metal.
Burnishing: I use this homemade burnisher built from the back end of a worn out carbide onsrud spiral router bit. As was said, if your burnisher scratches, it's too soft. I use 10 firm strokes parallel to the top, followed by 5 or 6 light ones on either face at about 10 degrees (like buttering toast - no more!) to draw out the hook (I feel for it with a fingernail). You can visibly see the three resulting facets on the edge - a thicker one in the middle, and two thinner ones outside where the hooks are.
The whole process takes only a minute or two.
In Japan, there's probably a WoodNet equivalent where they're debating about Western chisels being a lot like Japanese plumbers. - AHill
Posts: 3,878
Threads: 0
Joined: Jun 2009
The info in the post has been very helpful, but do you do anything different for smaller end of a gooseneck scraper? I have no problems on the straight ones and even OK on the large end of the gooseneck, but the small end has me stymied.
Steve
