I suspect that HD cabinet is made with some lower cost wood, like maple, and the color is done with a lacquer toner. I made this tall maple and birch ply bath cabinet to match the vanity and mirror in the photo.
I believe the color was called cinnamon, but it's clearly not as red as your "warm cinnamon". In any case, I did it by spraying shellac + Transtint dye toner coats followed by a clear topcoat. You can get any color you want doing this.
Here's a vanity I made last Winter that had to match the color sample in front of it.
The sample is maple, the vanity is cherry. Why the woman wanted cherry to be stained like that I have no clue, but that's what she wanted so that's what I did. In this case I got the right color and look by using a SW BAC Wiping Stain and then my topcoats.
I'm sure you could get the color you want either way, but I think the toner approach would be best based on how it looks to me in the photo. If you are not proficient with a spray gun, however, then toners are out and you would be left with the wiping stain approach as the best option. SW's BAC Wiping Stains are amazing; nothing like stains you have probably used. Great color in one coat, easy to use, fast drying. If you go that route, alder might be a good choice of wood to start with as the base color is close. Cherry likely would work, too; I just hate staining cherry.
John
I forgot to mention that the SW BAC Wiping Stain was custom mixed by SW. I took the color sample and some raw cherry pieces with me and we modified one of their stock colors until it matched. It took about 4 adjustments and maybe 30 minutes. No extra charge either. At around $23/qt it is a real bargain in my book.
John