It has certainly been an incredible learning project! I understand now why it is somewhat of a tradition for beginners to build a bench as a first or nearly first project (this is my third project). Because of the various mistakes I've made, I'm sure I'll want to build another sometime down the road, but my confidence level has gone way up after learning so much here.
So anyway, here's one especially for mpphoto:
Upsy-daisey:
The top sits on the base on two 3/4" dowels, and I stuck a couple lag screws in it also.
I'm very happy with it. It is rock solid, night-and-day difference between it and the old base. I push and pull on the bench from every angle and it doesn't budge! This was definitely worth the extra time, effort, and money to rebuild it. I had my doubts for a while, but now that it's all together, I'm very glad I redid it. My only regret is that I didn't spring for the maple instead of poplar. But that also saved me about $150. I think that means I'm entitled to spend that $150 on a tenon saw.
Or a nice dovetail saw... or a shoulder plane... or...
This is exciting... it means part II of the adventure will begin soon: the cabinets!
So.... does anyone want a slightly used, light duty dougfir and poplar stand...
Turning impaired.