(10-20-2020, 08:32 AM)briman87 Wrote: I have read and seen on multiple videos one being the wood whisperer that simple green is fine to use, maybe the old formula was similar to oven cleaner. Do you happen to have an SDS sheet for the one you have. Of all the users on this thread you are the only one saying that Simple Green is bad to use. Charles from Freud has even said that he has personally used simple green
OMG, the whisperer said it, it must be true.
He's talented and I like him, but he'll pimp anything that benefits him at that moment. Then poof ; no loner flavor of the month. I've heard from several old timers that swear by oven cleaner, and i read about it in a magazine. And I've used it myself and am still hear and have that sawblade. I think you know where I'm headed...............
No, I don't keep SDS sheets at hand, especially for products that I don't use. Frankly I don't care whether you believe or agree with me, or even if it's true, or was true of the old stuff and no longer. I've laid out why I think SG is a non stater. The biggest is it's not better than other things, nor is it cheaper. In and of itself that's a good enough reason for me to choose something else. The confusion over which type of SG is suitable - or not - is secondary. As is whether I got the dilution ratio correct.
Quickest confirmation with the relative info from SG's regulatory officer:
https://sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?...mple+green
This is the thread that touched off the discussion 15 years ago:
https://ncwoodworker.net/forums/index.ph...post-12417
....and a followup :
https://ncwoodworker.net/forums/index.ph...ost-108040
And another email re-print from an SG email on the subject circa 2010:
https://sawmillcreek.org/showthread.php?...Saw-Blades
Maybe most telling is what SG themselves recommends, and it ain't regular SG:
https://simplegreen.com/cleaning-tips/ro...aw-blades/
So, I put it to you again - given that SG is not better or cheaper, why take a chance whether you've got HD, extreme, or aircraft instead of regular ? Or whether I'm soaking or spray and wipe. Might as well use oven cleaner. Lots of guys have been lucky with that, and it works too !
Quote:Charles from Freud has even said that he has personally used simple green
Got a link to that ?
Quote:Kev and all,
Kerosene is the recommended solvent to clean Freud carbide tips. Soak overnight in a sealed container and brush clean with a stiff nylon bristle brush. Some time ago I posted images taken with a SEM of damage done to carbide by a commercially available bit and blade cleaner. It is not myth or legend that strong caustics and strong acids will deteriorate carbide. This link should take you to the information that Simple Green has published on the matter:
http://www.simplegreen.com/solutions...20Saw%20Blades
Quote:Charles M
Freud America, Inc.
Y'all should use whatever pleases and works for you. Plenty of effective choices out there. Only, some are better than others. Even soaking in water overnite and scrubbing with a brush the next morn will clean some blades.