(10-21-2024, 10:55 PM)Tapper Wrote: ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
I was wondering how long it would take for this post to appear. ...
This is a great discussion, and I very much appreciate the advice and opininos.
One thing that occurs to me is that you all may not appreciate how large and tall this room is for a bathroom. Most bathrooms just are not like this one and so it is hard to imagine why anything else but tile would be appropriate. Maybe I am wrong, but I invite you to look at the measurements in the drawing and imagine a 12 foot cathedral ceiling besides. Its is a small barn. It has five rooms in it (counting the shower).
As for using cement board, I tend to use Schluter products and have used their DITRA menbranes on several projects elsewhere in the house, including on this same level when I expanded and remodeled the children's/guest bath down the hall. Frankly, I cannot recall, but when I researched it many years ago, I am pretty sure cement board was for flatness and water stability, not structure. But I could be wrong. I studied all the TCA specs and standards and, at the time, only DITRA met the specs for tile to substrate decoupling needed to handle the flex.
Anyway, I honestly and sincerely appreciate all the thoughts and discussion points provided and fro the time you all have taken to express them.
We have a lot to think about and consider as we review the approach to the flooring.