Posts: 1,804
Threads: 0
Joined: Nov 2006
Location: SF Bay Area
(10-26-2019, 07:28 PM)jteneyck Wrote: You can pin loose tenons, too, just like you can with integral tenons, if that's something you want to do. With loose tenons, however, you obviously need to pin the tenon in both the stile and rail.
Does pinning significantly strengthen the loose tenon's attachment to the rail?
(I had assumed this was mostly to hold the joint tight as the glue sets and then as a secondary reinforcement to the cross-grain joint in the stile.)
Matt
Posts: 12,675
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2010
Location: Lewiston, NY
(10-27-2019, 03:48 PM)mdhills Wrote: Does pinning significantly strengthen the loose tenon's attachment to the rail?
(I had assumed this was mostly to hold the joint tight as the glue sets and then as a secondary reinforcement to the cross-grain joint in the stile.)
Matt
Your assumptions are correct. Pinning any glued M&T type joint doesn't increase the ultimate breaking strength. The only benefit is if the glue fails the joint won't fall apart.
Before there were exterior glues doors were made with draw bored M&T joints or with wedged thru tenons. In those cases, the pins and wedges were critical to the strength of the joint.
John
Posts: 1,019
Threads: 0
Joined: Feb 2008
I would use stave construction for stiles. I've built several exterior doors and have had a couple issues with solid wood stiles bowing after a period of time.
"This is our chance, this our lives, this is our planet we're standing on. Use your choice, use your voice, you can save our tomorrows now." - eV
Posts: 24,327
Threads: 0
Joined: Feb 2002
Location: Elizabethtown, KY
How about dovetail joints?
Center layer will be 1" to hold the glass panel; outsides will be 3/4" or less.
Yes, I've been accused of "over engineering"
"Truth is a highway leading to freedom" --Kris Kristofferson
Wild Turkey
We may see the writing on the wall, but all we do is criticize the handwriting.
(joined 10/1999)
Posts: 12,675
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2010
Location: Lewiston, NY
(10-28-2019, 05:43 PM)Wild Turkey Wrote: How about dovetail joints?
Center layer will be 1" to hold the glass panel; outsides will be 3/4" or less.
Yes, I've been accused of "over engineering"
M&T, loose tenons, or dowels. Stick with what has been proven to work.
It's fine to use a 3 layer laminate for the stiles and rails, but the joinery should be buried inside to protect it from the weather.
John
Posts: 23,946
Threads: 2
Joined: Sep 2003
Location: Missouri
Yea, no sense in going a different route and have it fail.
Steve
Mo.
I miss the days of using my dinghy with a girlfriend too. Zack Butler-4/18/24
The Revos apparently are designed to clamp railroad ties and pull together horrifically prepared joints
WaterlooMark 02/9/2020
Posts: 39,555
Threads: 0
Joined: Apr 2007
Grout was great for info on this type thing
Phydeaux said "Loving your enemy and doing good for those that hurt you does not preclude killing them if they make that necessary."
Phil Thien
women have trouble understanding Trump's MAGA theme because they had so little involvement in making America great the first time around.
Posts: 2,336
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2008
Location: Irving, Tx
A 48" wooden door is huge. "Over engineering" may be appropriate. Since John said three layers is okay, I think doing extra long dove tails on the center layer would be stronger (more solid) than pined loose tenons. There's my humble opinion.
"I tried being reasonable..........I didn't like it." Clint Eastwood
Posts: 24,327
Threads: 0
Joined: Feb 2002
Location: Elizabethtown, KY
(10-28-2019, 06:14 PM)jteneyck Wrote: the joinery should be buried inside to protect it from the weather.
John
There will be an 8' roof overhang so it will be protected from most weather.
"Truth is a highway leading to freedom" --Kris Kristofferson
Wild Turkey
We may see the writing on the wall, but all we do is criticize the handwriting.
(joined 10/1999)
Posts: 12,675
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2010
Location: Lewiston, NY
(10-29-2019, 07:21 AM)Bill Holt Wrote: A 48" wooden door is huge. "Over engineering" may be appropriate. Since John said three layers is okay, I think doing extra long dove tails on the center layer would be stronger (more solid) than pined loose tenons. There's my humble opinion.
I respectfully disagree. Go make a couple of test pieces and you will see that a dovetail doesn't have as much racking resistance in that direction as you might think. Yes, it's strong, but the joint moves a little unless it's cut perfectly. You can't pull a DT joint tight with clamps during glue up either (if you can it wasn't cut very well) and not even a perfectly cut DT joint will ever be as tight as any of the other three when they are clamped up. Glued surface area is what gives a joint strength; again, a DT loses badly to any of the other three. Also, you wouldn't be able to use cope/stick joinery, or any sort of dado and stub tenon for alignment of the stiles/rails because DT's have to go together from 90's. And then how do you glue on the outer two layers and get everything perfectly aligned?
Three layer laminate construction is done before you size the frame members to final dimensions. Laminates sometimes aren't exactly flat after glue up, but being oversized allows you to mill them perfectly flat again and then cut to final dimensions. If you could somehow deal with the alignment problem of the outer laminates only to end up with one or more members of your now glued up door having a bow how would you deal with it?
After what I'm sure were lots of failures the old guys ended up doing things a certain way because those things worked. A 48" wide door is large but nothing compared to any door on a cathedral. Some of those are 6 or 8 ft wide and 15 or more feet high. Go look at how they were put together.
John
|
