+- Woodnet Forums (https://forums.woodnet.net)
+-- Thread: which thickness planer (/showthread.php?tid=7316324)
Pages:
1
2
which thickness planer - woodrat57 - 07-11-2016
I'm in the market for a new planer. My Delta 22-540 started making clattering noises yesterday, and the feed rollers quit working. After reading an earlier post here about Delta, I think I will stay away. So I am looking for suggestions, I've read that the Dewalt 735W gets good reviews, but thats a bit steep for me. I am just a hobbyist and am looking for a good machine that's a decent price. Thanks for any suggestions.
Re: which thickness planer - ®smpr_fi_mac® - 07-11-2016
I would search for an older, American-made, cast iron unit. It may require some maintenance, such as new bearings and pulleys, but you'll likely end up with a better, less expensive tool.
Unless you require a bench top, then I can't help you there.
Re: which thickness planer - Bill Wilson - 07-11-2016
Pull the side cover off of your Delta and look to see if the drive pulley for the cutterhead may have come off. I recall there was an issue with this happening a few years ago.
Re: which thickness planer - goaliedad - 07-11-2016
Check the drive pulley as suggested. Make sure the key is still in place
I have a Ridgid and am happy with it- other than HD no longer stocks the blades. The only "portable" I would consider us the Dewalt- I hate being jerked around by HD.
I would look for a used Dewalt if I were you. Personally, my next planer will be a heavy, stay in place piece of cast iron.
Re: which thickness planer - dg152 - 07-11-2016
If I was in the market today for another planer I would go with the Dewalt 735W. My impression is that it's the best "portable" planer in it's size. Yes, it's pricey but they come up on craigslist all the time. The other option may be the Ridgid planer available at Home Depot. I've read good things about them, as well. Have fun shopping around and let us know what you end up with.
Re: which thickness planer - Dave Diaman - 07-11-2016
The planer you have is a decent planer as far as lunchbox planners go. If it were me unless I was going to upgrade to a 15-20" machine I would try to repair what you have. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense to spend $500 to buy basically the same exact planer you have when you can repair the one you have for a few dollars. I would just start taking it apart until you find the problem and order the replacement part. Worst case is you still have a planer that doesn't work. There are a few companies out there that still stock the parts you would need. I just rebuilt a dewalt SCMS and can give you the parts supplier if you need it. They carry Delta parts also.
Re: which thickness planer - Wild Turkey - 07-12-2016
Where are you located? I know of a couple of planers near Louisville!
Re: which thickness planer - rwe2156 - 07-12-2016
I'm will to bet it can be fixed.
If you have a DW service center nearby I would take it and get a diagnosis, then decide if its worth the repair.
Re: which thickness planer - goaliedad - 07-12-2016
I had a delta lunch box- recurring issue was the drive pulley would loosen up. Even with lock tight. Eventually the key way in the pulley and shaft got nasty. Enter my Ridgid. See my earlier post regarding the Ridgid
Re: which thickness planer - Lynden - 07-14-2016
Check the Makita 2012NB reviews. It's pricey but relatively quiet (1/4 the noise of the DeWalt DW735). If you're considering a 735, definitely find one to listen to before you buy.
https://www.amazon.com/Makita-2012NB-12-Inch-Interna-Lok-Automated/dp/B000051ZOO