+- Woodnet Forums (https://forums.woodnet.net)
+-- Thread: Best and Worst of 2016 (/showthread.php?tid=7325972)
Best and Worst of 2016 - AHill - 12-07-2016
As we approach the end of the year, I thought I'd start a thread to allow some discussion. I'll start. Woodworking related answers only, please!
What was the best new tool introduced in 2016?
Hard to say on this one. The upgrade to the Veritas Plow was good. The introduction of the Veritas mortise chisels was welcome.
What was the biggest disappointment in 2016?
Still no Lie-Nielsen plow plane. Prototype rolled out in October-ish 2013. Still "working out the bugs" more than 3 years later. When does a prototype become an antique?
Most significant loss of woodworking talent?
Leonard Lee. A giant in the industry. 'Nuff said.
Vladamir Kagan. Google him. He was innovative.
Nomination for best / most interesting / most controversial thread of the year.
Best thread: Derek Cohen's thread on the tall lingerie chest he made for his wife. Design, problem solving, and craftsmanship all rolled into one.
Most controversial thread: Any rehash of bevel up vs. bevel down with references to chip breaker setting.
What new skill did you learn this year?
For me, it was using a bowl gouge to hollow out the inside of bowls without getting catches.
RE: Best and Worst of 2016 - JimBelair - 12-07-2016
(12-07-2016, 02:10 PM)AHill Wrote: Vladamir Kagan. Google him. He was innovative.
I did and you're right. Iconic design.
A bit of a cop out but I can't argue with any of your other selections either.
Good idea for a thread.
RE: Best and Worst of 2016 - C. in Indy - 12-08-2016
Lots of people piled on in defense of the No. 6 size plane, despite Patrick Leach's opinion
RE: Best and Worst of 2016 - jppierson - 12-08-2016
I believe the most controversial thread(s) were about the Saw Stop / Bosch Reaxx. Lottttttts of pertinent discussion and lines in the sand.
RE: Best and Worst of 2016 - AndyM - 12-09-2016
Leonard Lee was a tremendous person and built a great company. He left it in his son's capable hands.
RE: Best and Worst of 2016 - Derek Cohen - 12-09-2016
Hi Allan
Thank you for the kind words, but most of all, thank you for the link to Vladamir Kagan. What an inspiration for us all!
Regards from Perth
Derek
RE: Best and Worst of 2016 - Mike Brady - 12-09-2016
Not that it is exactly a life-changer, but its possible that the many of the first generation of L-N customers may never have a chance to use a plow plane from this maker. Meanwhile, their closest competitor has designed, sold, and then redesigned their version.