04-03-2018, 09:06 AM
My search for the perfect cabinet assembly screw continues.
This research article (rather scholarly and dense, and required 3 readings to fully understand) tested Confirmat screws, screws and mini-fix connectors in particle board, plywood and MDF in various thicknesses.
The chart shows "moment" (yield strength, or "joint failure") in Newtons/Meter. It does not matter. What matters is the relative strengths.
http://www.proligno.ro/ro/articles/2015/..._final.pdf
Chart #4 shows the yield in 18mm (undersize 3/4" = 0.709") as follows:
18 mm Plywood Confirmat screw 98.10
18 mm Plywood Screw 84.86
18 mm PB Screw 44.14
18 mm PB Confirmat screw 41.69
18 mm MDF Confirmat screw 60.82
18 mm MDF Screw 60.33
about a 16% increase in strength.
Apparently the Confirmat screw behaves like both a screw and a dowel. It provides both angular support and pull-out strength.
In MDF the difference in strength between the Confirmat and the screw are negligible. But the difference in particle bard is significant. And comparing plywood to particle board, the plywood joints are more than twice as strong.
I am going to try the 7 x 50mm Confirmat screws.
This research article (rather scholarly and dense, and required 3 readings to fully understand) tested Confirmat screws, screws and mini-fix connectors in particle board, plywood and MDF in various thicknesses.
The chart shows "moment" (yield strength, or "joint failure") in Newtons/Meter. It does not matter. What matters is the relative strengths.
http://www.proligno.ro/ro/articles/2015/..._final.pdf
Chart #4 shows the yield in 18mm (undersize 3/4" = 0.709") as follows:
18 mm Plywood Confirmat screw 98.10
18 mm Plywood Screw 84.86
18 mm PB Screw 44.14
18 mm PB Confirmat screw 41.69
18 mm MDF Confirmat screw 60.82
18 mm MDF Screw 60.33
about a 16% increase in strength.
Apparently the Confirmat screw behaves like both a screw and a dowel. It provides both angular support and pull-out strength.
In MDF the difference in strength between the Confirmat and the screw are negligible. But the difference in particle bard is significant. And comparing plywood to particle board, the plywood joints are more than twice as strong.
I am going to try the 7 x 50mm Confirmat screws.
No animals were injured or killed in the production of this post.